How to Ask Your Boss for Feedback (and Actually Get It) | The Manager Track Episode 339
EPISODE 339 · ~16 min

How to Ask Your Boss for Feedback (and Actually Get It)

If “you’re doing great” is all you’ve heard from your boss this year, here’s why they stay vague, the questions that get you a real answer, and what to do when your manager still says “all good.”

THE MANAGER TRACK
How to Ask Your Boss for Feedback (and Actually Get It)
EP 339 · WITH RAMONA SHAW
feedbackmanaging upexpectationscareer growth
Episode 339 cliff notes cover

Get the Episode 339 cliff notes

The questions that assume there’s an answer, a fill-in email to put expectations in writing, what to say when the feedback stings, a self-assessment for when your boss still says “all good,” and a worksheet. 6 pages, free.

Free, 6 pages, sent to your inbox. You’ll also get Archova’s weekly leadership newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime.
Check your inbox

Your Episode 339 cliff notes are on the way. If you don’t see them in a few minutes, check your promotions or spam folder.

Download the PDF now

What we cover

“You’re doing great, keep it up.”

If that’s the only feedback you’ve had from your boss this year, and your rating came back as “meets expectations,” you’re in good company. In Gallup’s 2024 data, only 46% of US employees strongly agreed that they know what’s expected of them at work, down from 56% in early 2020.

And the higher you go, the vaguer it tends to get: fewer clear metrics, less feedback, and no real answer on which decisions are yours to make. Some of that comes with a bigger role. But if you want to keep growing, guessing where you stand isn’t much of a plan.

In Episode 339 of The Manager Track, Ramona explains why bosses stay vague (none of the reasons are about you), how to ask in a way that gets you a real answer, and what to do when you’ve asked well a few times and still hear “all good.”

In this episode, you’ll hear about:

  • What a study of 387 managers found about asking for negative feedback versus positive feedback
  • 3 questions that assume there’s an answer, so “you’re doing great” stops being the easy reply
  • The question that turns vague expectations into 3 written goals, and the email to send the same day
  • What to do in the meeting when the feedback stings, and why your reaction decides whether you’ll hear the truth next time
  • How to get input from a boss who still says “all good”: bring your own assessment and let them react to it

If you’ve ever walked out of a review still wondering what you’d have needed to do differently, this episode is for you.

Free cliff notes: the questions, the same-day email and the self-assessment on 6 pages. Get them here.

Watch the episode

Watch Episode 339 on YouTube

Timestamps

00:00“You’re doing great, keep it up”
01:40Why bosses stay vague: 3 reasons
02:55The research on asking for negative feedback
03:25Ask specific, forward-looking questions
04:00Ask about the measure
05:35Ask about decision rights
06:10Timing: ask in January, not December
06:50How to react to the feedback
08:25The keep, start, stop test
09:00Make it a monthly habit
09:35The Leadership Accelerator
10:25When you still get nothing: bring your own assessment
12:45Go to other sources and use your data
13:20“Why do I have to do all the heavy lifting?”
14:40Recap and what to do this week

Resources mentioned

  • Gallup, “U.S. Employee Engagement Sinks to 10-Year Low” (January 2025): read the article
  • Gartner, “47% of Managers Say They Are Working Harder Than One Year Ago” (April 2026): read the press release
  • Susan Ashford and Anne Tsui, “Self-Regulation for Managerial Effectiveness: The Role of Active Feedback Seeking,” Academy of Management Journal (1991): read the abstract
  • Episode 338, How to Write a Performance Review: 5 Steps for Managers: listen here
  • Episode 305, How to Give Your Manager Feedback (Without Damaging the Relationship): listen here
  • Leadership Accelerator, Archova’s 12-week program for new and early-stage managers
  • Executive Presence Intensive, Archova’s 8-week program for experienced leaders working on managing up, clarity and promotion
  • Free masterclass on how to lead successfully as a new manager: archova.org/masterclass
  • The Confident and Competent New Manager: archova.org/books
  • Episode 339 cliff notes: get them here

Links

  • Schedule a Leadership Strategy Call with Ramona HERE.
  • Grab the free New Manager Toolkit: archova.org/free-toolkits
  • Learn how to turn your 1-on-1 meetings from time wasters, awkward moments, status updates, or non-existent into your most important and valuable meeting with your directs all week. Learn more at: archova.org/1on1-course
  • Grab your copy of Ramona’s best-selling book ’The Confident & Competent New Manager: How to Rapidly Rise to Success in Your First Leadership Role’: amzn.to/3TuOdcP

Related episodes

What’s next?

  • Learn more about our leadership development programs, coaching and workshops at archova.org.
  • Want to better understand your leadership style and patterns? Take our free quiz to discover your Manager Archetype and learn how to play to your strengths and uncover your blind spots: archova.org/quiz
  • Are you in your first manager role and don’t want to mess it up? Watch our FREE Masterclass and discover the 4 shifts to become a leader people love to work for: archova.org/masterclass
  • Love the podcast and haven’t left a review yet? All you have to do is go to ramonashaw.com/itunes and to our Spotify Page, and give your honest review. Thanks for your support of this show!
  • If this episode inspired you in some way, take a screenshot of you listening on your device and post it to your Instagram Stories, and tag me @ramona.shaw.leadership or DM me on LinkedIn at linkedin.com/in/ramona-shaw
Read the full transcript

00:00“You’re doing great, keep it up”

You’re doing great, keep it up.

If that’s the only feedback you’ve heard from your boss this year, and then your rating came back kind of average, or meeting expectations, then this episode is for you.

My name is Ramona Shaw, and this is The Manager Track Podcast. If you want the cliff notes to this episode, make sure to check out the show notes.

Last week, in the previous episode, we talked about writing reviews for your team. Today we’re on the other side of the table.

A lot of the managers I work with have a boss who stays vague. And actually, the higher up you go in an organization, often the more vague the feedback is, or the less feedback you get. No really clear metrics, no real feedback, and no clarity on which decisions are really theirs to make, what they need to own and what they shouldn’t. And so oftentimes, these leaders are left guessing.

Now, part of setting the direction and having more agency and responsibility, that’s just part of the job. But there’s also still that component of, no, I do want to grow, I do want to get better. And if that desire doesn’t get satisfied, you’re not alone. That’s fairly typical. In a Gallup survey from late 2024, only 46% of US employees strongly agreed that they know what is expected of them at work. That was down from 56% in early 2020.

Here’s what we’re going to cover today. First, why bosses stay vague, so that you stop taking it personally. Second, how to ask for feedback in a way that actually gets you an answer. And third, what to do when you still get nothing.

01:40Why bosses stay vague: 3 reasons

So let’s start with why bosses or managers stay vague with their feedback. There are basically 3 reasons your boss isn’t telling you how you’re doing.

One, they’re busy. Your manager’s probably stretched across more people and more priorities than a few years ago. A Gartner survey published this spring found that 47% of managers say more is expected of them and they’re working harder than just a year ago. Feedback for someone who’s doing fine is the first thing to drop.

Two, criticism is uncomfortable. A lot of managers would rather say, “You’re doing great, you’re doing fine, all is well,” than have the awkward conversation, especially if it’s someone they like on a personal level. That makes it even harder.

And then three, and this one surprises people, is that they may not have a clear picture themselves. If nobody has defined what excellent looks like in your role, your boss can’t fully tell where you stand and what to compare that against.

Now, none of these reasons are actually about you, but knowing what they are will allow you to change how you ask and increase the probability that you actually get something valuable back from your manager. So with that, let’s talk about how to do the asking.

02:55The research on asking for negative feedback

There’s a piece of research I want you to know before we get into the details. Susan Ashford and Anne Tsui studied 387 managers and how their bosses, peers and direct reports saw them. Managers who sought negative feedback understood more accurately how others evaluated them, and they were seen as more effective overall. Managers who sought positive feedback were seen as less effective.

So the worry that asking makes you look insecure is half right. Asking what you could do better is what actually helps. And here’s what that looks like in practice.

03:25Ask specific, forward-looking questions

First, stop asking, “How am I doing?” or “Do you have any feedback for me?” That question invites “great,” something ambiguous, something vague: “No, all is good.” Instead, ask something specific and forward-looking. For example: What’s one thing I could do differently that would make your job easier? If you had to pick one area where I’m not yet at the level you need me to be, what would that be? Or, what would someone at the next level be doing that I’m not doing yet?

Notice that each of those assumes that there is an answer. It’s not, “Is there anything?” No, we’re asking, “What is it?” And that makes it easier for your boss to actually come up with something and give it to you, because you’re not asking whether or not there is anything missing. You’re saying, “What is the thing that’s missing?”

04:00Ask about the measure

Second, ask about the measure and not just the feedback. Let me give you an example. Let’s say a client of mine, a director, has no clear metrics for her role. She stops asking how she’s doing and instead asks her boss this: “When you look back at this year, what are the 3 things that would make you say I had a strong year?”

You obviously ask that ahead of time. Okay, let’s pretend it’s June of next year, or it’s the end of the year: what are the 3 things that would make you say this was a strong year? Then she writes it down, and the same day she sends a short email saying, “Hey, here’s what I heard. These are the 3 things. Did I get that right?”

That email does a lot of work. It turns a vague conversation into something written down, and it gives you a reference point for your review down the line. And as we’re coming closer to year-end, it’s a great question to ask if you’re having a hard time pinning down expectations. Sometimes it’s even when managers change, or when there is a vacuum of leadership and you don’t know yet who’s going to review your performance in the future. Try to get this in writing, so you have something to anchor on when needed.

05:35Ask about decision rights

Third, ask about decision rights. A vague boss often means vague authority too. So ask: “Which decisions do you want me to make without checking with you, and which ones do you want to see first?”

You’ll be surprised how often the answer is, “In these areas, you can just decide that.” And all along you’ve been waiting for permission you didn’t actually need, while they may even be wondering why you’re bothering them with this. So check in. What decision authority do you have? How much agency do you have? And is that aligned with what your boss wants you to take on?

06:10Timing: ask in January, not December

And the timing matters here. Don’t wait until the very end, right before your performance review, to have those conversations. If you ask about the measure in January, you have 11 months to hit it. If you ask in December, you’re going to find out what the target was after the year is already over, and there’s nothing you can do about it, because your review cycle is about to close.

So use this conversation, and what we’re talking about here, to set yourself up for success next year. For example, you can say: “Before we finalize this year, I want to make sure I’m clear on next year. What would make next December’s review an easy conversation for both of us? What are the expectations or the metrics I need to hit?”

06:50How to react to the feedback

Now, how you react to the answer matters as much as the question, so don’t underestimate your reaction here. If your boss gives you something critical and you start to explain, defend or add context for the next 5 minutes, what they will learn is that honest feedback costs them time and energy they probably don’t feel they have. And so they won’t do it again, or they’re just less likely to.

So here’s a simple rule. In the same meeting where you receive the feedback, don’t explain. Ideally, just say thank you, maybe ask a clarifying question if it’s not specific enough, and then stop. “Thank you, that’s useful. Can you give me an example of when you saw that?” Or, “Thank you, that’s useful. I’m going to think about this and get back to you with a game plan.”

If you disagree with the actual feedback, think about it for a day and then bring it back. There are some exceptions to this, but in most cases you’ll have a much better conversation. For example: “Hey, I thought about what you said about the launch update. I see part of it, and here’s why I see it a bit differently.” Not, “Here’s where I think you’re wrong,” but, “Here’s where I see it a bit differently, and here’s what I’m going to change either way.” That shows you took it seriously, and it keeps the door open for the next round of feedback.

08:25The keep, start, stop test

And one more note here. This is a test you can use after any feedback conversation with your boss. When you walk out, can you write down one thing to keep doing, one thing to start doing and one thing to stop? If a feedback conversation ends and you can’t, the conversation was likely too vague, and your follow-up email is where you address that and ask for the specifics or the examples.

The one thing to keep doing is where we hope you also received some positive feedback: something they appreciated, or something they called out as a strength of yours.

09:00Make it a monthly habit

Now, all these questions, realigning on expectations and clear goals, is not a one-time event. This should turn into a habit. In our programs we work on leadership systems, and this is one part of your routine that goes into your leadership system. So pick one of the questions and make it a practice to ask it once a month in a one-on-one with your manager. When asking becomes a routine, it also stops being awkward for both of you, and your manager learns that you’re keeping track of it, which helps them be better prepared as well.

09:35The Leadership Accelerator

Now, as we’re talking about this: if you’re a new manager and managing up is one of the things nobody taught you, I want to tell you about the Leadership Accelerator. This is our 12-week program for new and early-stage managers, people who are great at their jobs and now have to become great at leading. We talk about these uncomfortable conversations, the leadership system, managing your relationship with your own boss, and getting the clarity you need to lead a team.

If you’re already advanced as a leader, but managing up, getting clarity and getting a promotion are top of mind for you, then check out our Executive Presence Intensive. It’s an 8-week program for exactly those situations.

10:25When you still get nothing: bring your own assessment

Okay, back to the episode. Now, what if you’ve asked well a few times and you’re still getting, “No, you’re great, everything’s going well,” with this undertone of, “Stop asking me, just do your job”?

Step 1: bring your own assessment. Write down how you’d rate yourself on the 3 things you think matter in your role and bring it to your next one-on-one. “Hey, just to quickly check in with you, here’s how I rate myself on these 3 things. Where would you put me differently, or what else do you have to add?” Again, we’re making it a question that assumes they have an answer, not “Is there anything missing?” which can easily be dismissed with, “Nope, that’s great.” We want them to respond with more than a yes or no.

We do this because it’s much easier for someone to react to something than to create something from scratch. If you give your manager a draft they can edit, you make it so much easier for them than coming up with a draft themselves.

For example, let’s assume there’s a manager who leads a team of 8, and his boss keeps saying, “All good.” So he writes down the 3 things: delivery of the 2 big projects, his team’s retention, and how well he’s working with the sales leaders. He rates himself strong on the first 2 and kind of okay on the third one. Then he brings that to his one-on-one. His boss reads it and says, “Okay, I’d actually put the sales relationship higher. What I would like more of is you bringing problems to me earlier.”

That’s the first useful piece of feedback he might have gotten in 6 months, and it took about 4 minutes in total. His boss had an opinion the whole time. They just needed something to react to for it to finally come out.

When someone says everything is great, don’t assume they never think about whether they like what you’re doing. It just means it’s not right there. There’s no recall in the moment, they don’t feel like they’ve processed it enough, it feels uncomfortable for them, or they don’t have the energy or the time. There are multiple reasons, but don’t assume it’s not there.

12:45Go to other sources and use your data

Step 2 is to go to other sources. That includes your peers, the stakeholders you work with and people in other teams. Ask them the same specific questions. They often see things your boss doesn’t, because your boss isn’t in all of the conversations and all the meetings. So collect that input as well.

And then step 3: use the data you already have. Did your project land on time? Did your team’s number move? Did people outside your team ask for you? That is feedback too. You can track all of that and bring it into your review conversation at year-end.

13:20“Why do I have to do all the heavy lifting?”

Now, if you hear me say this and think, “Well, Ramona, why do I have to do all the heavy lifting? Isn’t that my boss’s job?” Ideally, yes, of course. In an ideal world, your manager would give you clear expectations and regular feedback. But if they don’t, you’re the one who pays the price. So waiting for them to change and deliver it to you on a silver platter usually costs you way more than it costs them.

And there’s a second reason to get good at this. Whatever you ask your boss for, your own team wants from you as well. So if you’ve ever been frustrated by “Oh, good, you’re doing great,” make sure your direct reports never get that from you. Going back to your leadership system, make sure you’re really good at tracking what they’re doing, giving them regular feedback, coaching them on the gaps and continuously leveraging their strengths as well. Give them the measures, the decision rights and specific feedback on a regular basis, without them having to come to you to see if they can get something out of you.

Last week’s episode of The Manager Track was on writing good reviews, so if you missed it, go check it out. That was Episode 338.

14:40Recap and what to do this week

Now, let me recap. Bosses are vague because they’re busy, because criticism is uncomfortable, and because they often don’t have a clear picture themselves. So ask specific, forward-looking questions, ask about the measure and the decision rights, and write back what you heard. Document it and send the email. Don’t defend in the moment, don’t over-explain, and if you still get nothing, bring your own assessment, go to other sources and use your own data.

If you’re up for it, here’s the first thing to do this week. In your next one-on-one, ask your boss what 3 things would make them say you had a strong Q1 of 2027, and then send the follow-up email the same day.

And if you want to go further, listen to Episode 305, How to Give Your Manager Feedback Without Damaging the Relationship. All these episodes will be linked in the show notes.

If this was useful, please hit like and subscribe, or share it with another manager who would benefit from it as well. Thanks so much, and see you next time.

If you enjoyed this episode, check out two other awesome resources to help you become a leader people love to work with. The first is a free masterclass on how to successfully lead as a new manager. Check it out at archova.org/masterclass. The second resource is my bestselling book, The Confident and Competent New Manager: How to Quickly Rise to Success in Your First Leadership Role. Check it out at archova.org/books, or head on over to Amazon and grab your copy there.

What listeners say

What our listeners are saying

★★★★★

“The only podcast I actually take notes on. Ramona’s frameworks have shown up verbatim in my last three 1:1s.”

Sarah
Engineering Manager
★★★★★

“I went from dreading feedback to running it like a system. This show is the reason.”

David
Product Lead
★★★★★

“No hype. No motivational fluff. Just the moves that actually work in real meetings.”

Priya
Director of Operations

Stop managing on instinct. Start leading with a system.

The Leadership Accelerator is a 12-week cohort program that helps new and early-stage managers build the skills, systems, and confidence to lead their teams well.

Scroll to Top