What we cover
When a meeting gets stuck, watch who gets it moving again. Often it’s someone who has barely spoken, and what they finally say is a question about what the conversation is for.
25 minutes into a 45-minute meeting, 2 people are still debating features, someone has started a side conversation about budget, and nobody has said what the meeting is supposed to produce. From the outside, the fix is easy to see. From inside the room, the instinct is to add your own view to the pile.
New managers do this a lot. Expertise is what got them promoted, so they keep proving their value with content: one more data point, one more update, one more opinion on the detail everyone is already arguing about. That makes them the expert in the room, and the meeting still has nobody leading it.
In Episode 336 of The Manager Track, Ramona explains that leading a meeting comes down to structure: deciding what the conversation is for, who needs to be heard, and how it ends. She shares 5 lines to use in the order they come up, from the opening to the close, and the research behind why each one works.
In this episode, you’ll hear about:
- The question to ask in the first 2 minutes that tells everyone what’s relevant
- Why the senior person should share their view after others, and how to bring in the people who haven’t spoken
- A question from strategy professor Roger Martin that gets 2 dug-in people out of a standoff
- How to state your position and name what would change your mind, and why research favors this over playing devil’s advocate
- What to say when someone hijacks the meeting or reopens a decision, plus a phrase your whole team can use to land a meeting that’s drifting
If your meetings end with everyone nodding and nobody sure what was decided, this episode is for you.
Free cliff notes: all 5 lines and every script from this episode on 6 pages. Get them here.
Watch the episode
Timestamps
Resources mentioned
- Steven Rogelberg on why groups underperform in meetings: strategy+business, “Bad meetings no more”
- Anita Williams Woolley and colleagues on collective intelligence (Science, 2010): summary on ScienceDaily
- Garold Stasser and William Titus on the hidden profile (1985): Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
- Charlan Nemeth and colleagues, “Devil’s advocate versus authentic dissent” (2001): European Journal of Social Psychology
- Roger Martin on “what would have to be true”: McKinsey Author Talks
- Leadership Accelerator, Archova’s 12-week program for new and early-stage managers
- Free masterclass on how to lead successfully as a new manager: archova.org/masterclass
- The Confident and Competent New Manager: archova.org/books
- Episode 336 cliff notes: get them here
Links
- Schedule a Leadership Strategy Call with Ramona
- Grab the free New Manager Toolkit mentioned in the episode: archova.org/free-toolkits
- Learn how to turn your 1-on-1 meetings from time wasters, awkward moments, status updates, or non-existent into your most important and valuable meeting with your directs all week. Learn more at: archova.org/1on1-course
- Grab your copy of Ramona’s best-selling book ‘The Confident & Competent New Manager: How to Rapidly Rise to Success in Your First Leadership Role’: amzn.to/3TuOdcP
Related episodes
- Episode 321, From Doer to Leader: Redefining Competence in Your New Role
- Episode 322, How to Read the Room: The 3 Questions Intuitive Leaders Ask
What’s next?
- Learn more about our leadership development programs, coaching and workshops at archova.org.
- Want to better understand your leadership style and patterns? Take our free quiz to discover your Manager Archetype and learn how to play to your strengths and uncover your blind spots: archova.org/quiz
- Are you in your first manager role and don’t want to mess it up? Watch our FREE Masterclass and discover the 4 shifts to become a leader people love to work for: archova.org/masterclass
- Love the podcast and haven’t left a review yet? All you have to do is go to ramonashaw.com/itunes and to our Spotify Page, and give your honest review. Thanks for your support of this show!
- If this episode inspired you in some way, take a screenshot of you listening on your device and post it to your Instagram Stories, and tag me @ramona.shaw.leadership or DM me on LinkedIn at linkedin.com/in/ramona-shaw
Read the full transcript
00:00Who gets a stuck meeting moving again
When a meeting gets stuck, pay attention to who gets it moving again. Very often that person has said less than anyone else in the room, and what they did say was a question about what the conversation was for.
So what I mean by leadership in a meeting in this context is structure: deciding what the conversation is for, who needs to be heard, and how it ends.
00:25What the research says about groups in meetings
Steven Rogelberg at UNC Charlotte studies meetings, and he’s looked at the research on whether groups actually solve problems better together than apart. The boost you’d expect from putting capable people in a room fails to show up 85 to 90% of the time. A typical meeting has plenty of ideas in it. What it’s usually missing is someone to give those ideas a shape.
00:50What this episode covers
So here’s what we’re going to cover: 5 lines, in the order they come up in a meeting. The opening, the discussion, the debate, the decision, and the close. Then the research behind them, what to do when someone hijacks the meeting, and a phrase your team can use to land a meeting that’s drifting.
My name is Ramona Shaw, and this is The Manager Track Podcast.
01:15Example: "What are we actually trying to decide today?"
Okay, let me give you an example. Look at a leader in a team meeting, 25 minutes into a 45-minute meeting about a new reporting tool. Two people on her team are going back and forth about features. Someone else has started a side conversation about budget. And nobody really has said what the meeting is supposed to produce. Not what are we supposed to talk about, but what are we aiming for in this meeting? What are we trying to achieve?
So the leader’s instinct is to jump in with her own view on the tool, which, you can all foresee, would quickly turn it into a further argument or discussion. Now, instead of that, she says, "Can I pause us for a second? What are we actually trying to decide today?" There’s a beat of silence, and then someone says, "Well, whether we pilot it next quarter." Half the debate stops mattering right there, since nobody needs to settle every feature to decide on a pilot. So they quickly decide to move ahead with the pilot, and the meeting ends 10 minutes early.
Now, as I’m describing this case to you, you can probably see how obvious it seems that someone would ask that question. But it’s obvious when we talk about it and we’re not actually the person in the meeting. We’re just observing and deciding what someone else should be doing. When we’re actually in the meeting, this happens all the time. We’re caught up talking about a side thing that we think matters, but that has nothing to do with what we’re actually trying to achieve in this conversation. And every so often, people actually have different opinions of what we’re trying to achieve.
03:00Brainstorm or decision: set the frame early
I remember someone giving me feedback once, saying, "It’d be really helpful if you clarified in the beginning of a meeting if we’re brainstorming or if you’re aiming to make a decision today." To me, that was a moment of reflection, to realize that sometimes I come in and I want to walk out with a clear decision. Sometimes I’m coming in saying, I have a problem and I’m looking to brainstorm how we can go about it, but the decision doesn’t need to happen or cannot happen today. And while I had that frame of mind walking into the meeting, the rest of the group didn’t. One smart person picked that up and gave me that feedback, which was very, very helpful. From then on, I try to always set the frame early on in a meeting, and I could quickly see how much of a difference it made when we were all on the same page from the start.
04:00Expert or leader: the habit that costs you authority
Now, the number 1 behavior that kills your authority in meetings is trying to prove your value by adding content. You add another data point, another update, another opinion on the detail everyone is already arguing about. New managers do this a lot, because content is what got them promoted. If you’re wondering what I mean by content: their expertise, demonstrating their competence and their knowledge, is what got them promoted and helped them stand out. But now, as a manager or as a leader, adding expertise in a meeting makes you the expert in the meeting, not the leader.
I want to clearly distinguish what I mean, because sometimes you as a leader do in fact have the deepest expertise, and so you’re sharing your expertise. But know that you’re then taking on the role of the expert, not the leader of the meeting. You’re playing two different roles, which is totally fine, but be aware that these roles are different. The person who shapes the conversation has more influence than the person with the best point in it. So the leader, not necessarily the expert, is the one with the influence. Two different roles. You’ve got to know which one you’re playing.
05:15Line 1: What are we here to decide?
Okay, so here are the 5 lines in the order you use them. The first one: "What are we here to decide or to brainstorm?" Say this in the first 2 minutes of a meeting. By doing so, you turn a discussion into a decision. Anything that you’re arguing about should be in service of that decision, right? It gives everyone a test for whether what they’re about to say is relevant. Is this something that is going to contribute to this decision, should we run the pilot or not? Or is this a detail that can wait until after we’ve actually made that decision?
Now, if nobody can answer it, propose an answer yourself: "I think we’re deciding whether to pilot this next quarter. Is that right?" And especially if you’re not the one who set up the meeting, opening with a question instead of determining it right away is the way to go. So instead of saying, "This is a decision-making meeting," you’re the one asking, "What decision or what topic are we aiming to brainstorm or decide on?"
If the honest answer is that the meeting isn’t deciding anything, say so and ask whether it needs to happen at all. And if there’s nothing to decide, make that clear as well: we’re here to get an update on this, or to brainstorm that. Set the outcome from the start.
06:45Line 2: Hear from people who haven’t spoken
The second sentence is: "Before I share where I am, I want to hear from people who haven’t spoken yet." Once the senior person in the room says what they think, the conversation will bend toward that. People who disagree go quiet, and people who were undecided start agreeing with the leader in the room. So hold your view back. If you truly and genuinely care about what people think, speak last, and use the time to bring in the people who haven’t said anything before you make your point.
You can call on them. Be specific about what you’re asking: "Sabrina, you’ve worked with this vendor before. What are we missing?" The person who’s been quiet often has a piece of information that nobody else in the room has. That’s why they’re in the room. That’s why everyone’s in the room, right?
07:40Line 3: What would have to be true?
So that was the second sentence. The third one is: "What would have to be true for this to work?" This one comes from Roger Martin, the strategy professor who wrote Playing to Win with A.G. Lafley. When two people are dug into opposite positions, arguing harder doesn’t move either of them. It sounds like a smart move, but it’s not effective. This question moves the conversation from positions to conditions. You stop debating whether it will work and start listening to what would need to hold, and conditions are something you can check for.
"Hey, let’s set aside whether it’s a good idea for a minute. What would have to be true for this to work?" By the way, this is a great way to negotiate as well, if the other person is inclined to say no. Then ask which condition the group, if it’s a group meeting, feels shakiest about. That’s where the real conversation is, and that’s where you want to spend your time.
08:40Line 4: Where I’m landing and what would change my mind
Okay, the fourth sentence is, "Here’s where I’m landing, and here’s what would change my mind." At some point, you do need to say what you think as the leader, the senior person in the room. This line lets you take a clear position without closing the door completely. People know you’ve made a call, and they know exactly what kind of argument would move you, which is a lot more useful than a general "Any thoughts on this?" Right? "Here’s where I’m landing: we pilot with one team. If the integration cost comes in over our budget, I will change my mind on this."
Now, a lot of people say, "Let me play the devil’s advocate," when they want to test an idea. In a minute, I’ll show you why the research says that backfires.
09:30Line 5: Who owns it and by when?
But first, let’s get to our fifth sentence: "So we’ve decided X. Who owns it and by when?" Say this in the last 5 minutes of a meeting, and do say it out loud, with a bit of a pause after, even when it feels obvious. A meeting that ends with, "Okay, good discussion, everyone took notes, we’re good to go," with everyone nodding their heads, means people will walk out with different memories of what was agreed. The test is whether everyone could repeat the decision the same way on their way out. "Okay, so we’re piloting with the design team, Markus owns the setup, and we’ll review results on the 15th. Did I get that right?" Everyone’s clear. Good.
10:15Using the lines in meetings you don’t run
Now, a quick side note here. You’ll be in plenty of meetings that you don’t run, including your boss’s meetings. Lines 1, 3, and 5 still work from that seat when you’re not leading. You might just want to rephrase them slightly, such as, "Can I check what we’re aiming to land today?" or, "Before we wrap, can I play back what I think we decided?" Whoever runs the meeting will likely be grateful that you stepped up and articulated it out loud, and everyone else in the room will appreciate that someone helped the meeting land and recapped the takeaways. So even if you’re not the one leading the meeting, use those phrases too.
11:00The Leadership Accelerator
If you want to build these types of habits with coaching and a group of peers, that’s what the Leadership Accelerator is for. This is our 12-week program for new and early-stage managers, and running meetings that end in real decisions is part of leading effectively. The Leadership Accelerator will help you become an effective leader, not just a strong expert: someone who can influence individual people, get them motivated, develop them through coaching and feedback, and also demonstrate authority and gain respect from your peers and from above. Our cohorts are small, so that the experience feels personal and we actually talk about what matters to you. If you want to find out whether you’d benefit from the program, check the link in the description.
11:45The research behind the 5 lines
Okay, let’s get back to the episode, and let me talk a little bit about research. There are 3 specific findings that explain why the lines we just reviewed actually work.
Anita Williams Woolley at Carnegie Mellon, with colleagues at MIT and Union College, put 699 people into groups of 2 to 5 and gave them a range of tasks, from puzzles to negotiations to brainstorming. The average IQ of the group and the IQ of its smartest member didn’t significantly predict how well the group did. But two things did: how evenly people took turns talking, and how well they read each other. Groups where one person dominated did the worst, which is why our second line was key.
Then there is what researchers call the hidden profile. Garold Stasser and William Titus set up group decisions where each person held some information only they knew, and the better option only became clear if people pooled those unique pieces. The groups spent their time on what everyone already knew, and they regularly missed the better option. That’s line 2 again, and it’s why the quiet person’s view matters so much.
And then Charlan Nemeth at UC Berkeley and her colleagues compared groups that heard a genuine dissenter with groups that heard someone assigned to play devil’s advocate. Real dissent produced more original thinking and more consideration of the other side. The devil’s advocate mostly made people dig in on their first position. And that’s line 4. When you state a clear position and mention the condition you attach to it, it invites real disagreement, and people know where the opening for disagreement is, what’s already settled, and where there’s room to negotiate. The devil’s advocate is still a useful tool, but it’s not as specific, and it often takes longer to get to the core of it, because people will play the devil’s advocate on basically everything that was up for discussion. So if you’re very clear on one part and want to leave room for the other, say so specifically.
13:55When someone hijacks the meeting
Now I want to briefly talk about what to do when someone hijacks the meeting. This is the defensive version, because sometimes the problem in a meeting is one single person: someone who dominates, takes the meeting on a tangent, or reopens a decision that’s already been made. You don’t need to confront them in the room to make your point, but you do need to bring the meeting back to its purpose, which is what the following line is for: "Let’s hold that for a second. First, what are we deciding today?" You’re not telling them to stop or to be quiet. You’re asking, "What is the purpose of this meeting?" and you’re asking them to pause. Typically, that will put an end to their tangent.
Now, for the person who reopens a closed decision, be firm here: "We decided that on the 4th. If something’s changed, tell me what, and we’ll look at it after this meeting." That protects the decision but still leaves a real door open. It still shows that decisions already made can change, but only if new information emerges, not just because someone feels like doubling down on it again with the same information. If you’re asking them to bring that to you after the meeting and they continue to do this and it’s becoming a pattern, make sure you bring it up in a one-on-one instead of in front of the entire group, and address the pattern of questioning decisions that have already been made.
15:30Landing gear: a phrase for your team
Okay, we’re moving on to a lighter scenario. Give your team a phrase anyone can use when a meeting drifts. Call it "landing gear," for example, and set it up in a calm moment, not in the heat of it. You can say, "Hey, new rule. If anyone feels like we’re circling, up in the air, say ’landing gear’ or ’let’s land the plane.’ Whoever’s running the meeting has to either name the decision that has been made or wrap up the meeting." It’s a way for us to say, I think we’re circling, and we need to put the landing gear out and land the plane.
Now, if you’re the leader, you can do this at any point in time. But for the people in the meeting with you, especially if you come across as somewhat authoritative or assertive, or some people may feel a bit intimidated by you, you have to give them the mandate. You have to say, "Everyone here should be calling this out when we fall into this pattern." It takes the awkwardness out of interrupting, because they now have the mandate to call it out when we’re circling and not landing the plane. Nobody has to tell a colleague that they’re wasting everyone’s time. No one has to make a sarcastic comment or a joke. They just call it, and everyone knows what it means and what to do next. By doing so, we’re cultivating the idea that we’re all equals and we’re a team, even if we all have different roles and levels of authority.
Let me give you a quick example. A team member says, "Hey, landing gear." The manager might say, "Okay, fair. We’re deciding whether the launch moves to March. Can we do that in the next 5 minutes?" And then the team member might say something like, "Yes, I think we can if finance signs off on the extra week." Then we move over to finance, and we can hopefully land that plane quickly.
17:40Why new managers talk more in meetings
Now here’s what people don’t say out loud. A lot of new managers talk more in meetings than they did before the promotion. Some of that is nerves, and some of it is feeling that you have to prove you deserve the seat. You have to demonstrate that you know what you’re talking about, that you’re competent, and that people can trust you because of your expertise. As an individual contributor, your value in meetings was your content, right? The analysis, the expertise, the answer, all of that. As a leader, your value is the structure that you give everyone else’s content, their contributions.
That takes some time getting used to, since it can feel like you’re contributing less and constantly asking your team to contribute. But your team needs that structure more than it needs another opinion from you. And if you notice they’re missing an opinion or a piece of information, it’s also a great opportunity to teach something, to follow up with coaching, and then expect that next time around there will already be more information in the room. Your job is to ask the right questions, to make sure people are sharing openly and transparently, that there is dissent and enough psychological safety in the room for people to disagree, and disagree effectively, and then to reach the outcome the meeting was intended to achieve.
19:10Try this in your next meeting
So if you want to take this to heart and try a fun experiment, only say a couple of lines, the lines we’ve talked about. Say the one in the beginning, say the one at the end, and try to say as little as possible in between, unless someone asks you directly. Then just sit back and watch how the meeting goes and how people treat you in it. So in the next meeting, will you be the person adding another point, or the person deciding what the points are for?
For a quick self-reflection, ask yourself how many of your meetings this week or last week ended with a decision, an owner, and a date, and how many were a little bit wishy-washy and unclear at the end. And why did no one speak up and clarify that? Also ask yourself who on your team has information that you keep missing because nobody’s asking them, or because they’re not showing up prepared, they’re not engaged, or they seem distracted. Then bring that up, not in the room, but with them one-on-one, or just call on them so they know that you want to hear from them.
20:25Recap
Now, if this was useful, please subscribe and share it with another leader you know who’d benefit from hearing the types of conversations we cover on The Manager Track Podcast.
As a quick reminder: the meeting belongs to the person who decides what the meeting is for, not the one who adds the smartest comment. Keep that in mind. Step into your leadership as a separate role from being the expert in the room. Remember, those are two different roles that you might play. There are likely other experts who can bring in the expertise. There’s likely no other leader in the room who can lead the meeting the way only you, as the leader, can. So don’t underestimate the importance of that role.
With that, I’ll see you next week with another episode of The Manager Track Podcast.
If you enjoyed this episode, check out two other awesome resources to help you become a leader people love to work with. The first is a free masterclass on how to successfully lead as a new manager. Check it out at archova.org/masterclass. The second resource is my bestselling book, The Confident and Competent New Manager: How to Quickly Rise to Success in Your First Leadership Role. Check it out at archova.org/books, or head over to Amazon and grab your copy there.